RSS

Last Son of Krypton

12 Jan

As part of my undergraduate course at Leicester there was a module called Journal of Special Topics. It involved everyone in the year working in groups of 3-4 and writing weekly ‘science’ reports that other groups would peer review and give feedback on. If a paper was good enough I would be submitted to the archive, if not it would have to be redone. One of the paper I submitted for my group was a look at the potential scientific explanations for the some of the powers displayed by Superman. I thought I’d put it up here in case anyone else wanted to give it a read.

Superman

Superman is a fictional DC superhero created in 1938. He is the last survivor of the alien planet of Krypton, having been sent to Earth as a child by his parents moments before their planet exploded [1]. On Earth he realised that radiation from our sun interacted with his physiology in such a way that he obtained superhuman powers; one of which, heat vision, will be the subject of discussion in this paper.

CO2 Vision

We will model his heat vision as a type of carbon dioxide laser. A CO2 laser works by using the vibration and rotations of a CO2 molecule to produce the laser light in the 10.6μm range [2]. This infrared beam is mainly used in industry for cutting, welding and engraving. Superman uses his heat vision for similar purposes and when you combine this with the fact that that this type of laser uses molecules readily found in the body it seems to be good choice for modeling his heat vision. Although in the comics and films Superman’s heat vision is primarily displayed as bright red beams this is probably more for visual effect. Add to this the fact that he is able to produce invisible beams it does not seem unreasonable to model his vision this way.

Photosynthesis

As stated, Superman’s main source of energy is through the absorption of solar radiation, a process which will be assumed to work in a similar manner to photosynthesis. Photosynthesis is a chemical process in plants that uses the energy from sunlight to convert CO2 into sugar and we can imagine that Superman’s biology stores the solar energy in a similar way. We will assume that he only absorbs sunlight through uncovered skin i.e. his hands and face, which was estimated to be an area of about 0.09 m^2 by assuming a 20cm diameter face and taking the front and back of hands measuring 8cm by 20cm. The process of photosynthesis in plants has a maximum efficiency of 11%, however on a molecular level the theoretical limit in efficiency is 25% which is the value we will assume Superman’s unique physiology possesses [3]. The amount of solar radiation incident on the Earth is on average 1367 W/m^2 [4] which means that at Earth the total amount of useful energy he absorbs is 29.76 J/s

Steel

Frequently Superman is shown using his heat vision to melt or cut through steel. The melting point of stainless steel is around 1713 K [5] and it has a specific heat and latent heat of fusion of 620 J/(kg.K) and 247,000 J/kg respectively. The total energy needed to melt room temperature steel is given by

Cm(T_{melt}-T_{room}) + Lm (1)

where m is the mass and C and L are the specific and latent heats. The density of stainless steel is 7900 kg/m^3 and so assuming his heat vision is focused on one pupil sized hole (3mm radius) in a 5cm thick piece of steel the total mass he would have to melt to cut through would be 0.0112 kg. If room temperature is taken to be 293 K then the total energy needed to melt the steel would be 12535.81 J. If his body was able to transfer the stored solar energy to his heat vision completely efficiently then he would need to bask in sunlight for 7 minutes and 2 seconds, however CO2 lasers are on average only about 20% efficient meaning he would need to be in sunlight for 35 minutes and 7 seconds.

Discussion

Absorbing sunlight and storing energy in a similar manner to photosynthesis gives Superman on average 29.76 joules of energy each second. In order to melt a single 3mm radius hole in a 5cm piece of steel he would have to spend just over 35 minutes absorbing solar radiation. If we assume all his powers run on solar radiation then it seems unlikely he would have enough energy to do all the amazing things he does on a regular basis. It is possible that his physiology is so unique and specially adapted that the efficiencies of absorbing and converting solar radiation are much higher than 25% and 20%. At the theoretical maximum of 100% he would be able to absorb and redirect 119 J/s which would mean he would only need 1 minute and 46 seconds worth of sunlight to melt the 3mm radius hole in steel.

Instead of increasing the efficiency of his biology we could also increase his surface area of absorption. If his height and weight are estimated to be 1.9 m and 102 kg then his surface area can be calculated using

Area(m^{2}) = \frac{[mass(kg)]^{0.425}[height(cm)]^{0.725}}{132.9} (2)

as 2.31m^2[6]. As was pointed out buy my source off biochemical knowledge, Andrew Westoby, obtaining 100% illumination would be quite difficult. However I will assume it can be done, simply as a means of obtaining a theoretical maximum to this process (and I’ve already probably got enough science wrong that one more thing won’t matter). Using the value of 2.31m^2 and the 25% and 20% efficiencies we find the time taken would be 1 minute 20 seconds. Combining both the total body surface area and the 100% efficiencies we get a time of just 4 seconds to absorb the energy required.

Conclusion

Assuming Superman’s absorption and heat vision processes are based around similar mechanism to photosynthesis and CO2 lasers, and assuming current maximum efficiencies for both these processes we find it would be possible to gain enough solar energy to melt steel, however, to do it frequently and in a manner similar to that depicted in the comics he would need to either surpass the quoted efficiencies or utilise more of his surface area in the process.

References

[1] J. Siegel, J.Shuster 1938 Action Comics, Vol. 1.
[2] R. Willingale, 2010, Lasers and Quantum Optics Lecture Notes
[3]http://www.fao.org/docrep/w7241e/w7241e05.htm#1.2.1 Viewed on 08/02/2011 at 23:44
[4]http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/SORCE/ Viewed on 08/02/2011 at 18:15
[5]http://www.matweb.com/search/DataSheet.aspx?MatGUID=71396e57ff5940b791ece120e4d563e0&ckck=1 Viewed on 08/02/2011 at 17:48
[6] D. DuBois, E. DuBois, 1916 Arch Intern Med 17 863-71

Advertisements
 
2 Comments

Posted by on January 12, 2012 in Blog

 

Tags: , , ,

2 responses to “Last Son of Krypton

  1. Andy Westoby

    January 18, 2012 at 11:36 am

    Yay! I’m a publishable source of information!

     

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: